Rothy’s Shoes Reviews – Must Read Before You Buy

When I first heard about Rothy’s, I was skeptical. Could shoes made from recycled plastic bottles really be comfortable, stylish, and sustainable? In 2025, with so many “greenwashed” brands in the market, I knew I had to try them myself to see if the hype held up. And after months of testing different pairs—through long workdays, city walks, and unexpected rain—I’ve got a lot to share.

Why I Finally Tried Rothy’s Shoes in 2025

I’ll be honest: I’ve always been picky with shoes. I want structure, support, sustainability, and of course—style. A friend raved about Rothy’s, and after spotting them online more times than I could count, I finally gave in. The brand’s mission to blend comfort with eco-conscious materials piqued my curiosity.

Where to Buy Rothy’s

Rothy’s keeps it simple. You can buy directly from their official website (rothys.com), which is where I ordered my first pair. They also have a mobile app that sometimes features exclusive deals. For in-person shoppers, Rothy’s operates physical stores in select U.S. cities, and I’ve also seen styles pop up on Nordstrom and Zappos.

Pro tip: check the “Final Few” section on their site—it’s their version of a clearance rack, and you might snag a pair for up to 50% off.

Do Rothy’s Run True to Size?

Mostly, yes—but not always.

I found that Rothy’s rounded-toe flats (like The Flat and The Loafer) run true to size. However, their pointed styles like The Point can feel a bit snug. If you’re in between sizes or have wider feet, I recommend going up half a size. They offer free exchanges, so there’s some flexibility if your fit isn’t perfect the first time.

Are Rothy’s Comfortable?

This was my biggest concern—and my biggest surprise.

When I first slipped on The Flat, it felt like wearing a sock with structure. The knit upper molded to my foot right away, and the cushioned insole (called the In Love™ footbed) offered a gentle bounce without feeling too squishy.

I’ve walked several miles in these without soreness, and they didn’t need any break-in period. Plus, since they’re machine washable, I didn’t hesitate to take them on rainy commutes or dusty strolls.

Do Rothy’s Have Arch Support?

Rothy’s shoes are known for a minimalist feel, so if you need heavy arch support, these might not be your go-to. That said, the insole does provide light to moderate support, enough for daily wear. I have mild arch sensitivity and felt supported throughout the day, especially in the sneaker and loafer styles.

Some styles like the Almond Loafer and the Driving Loafer offer a bit more structure underfoot. If you’re very particular, you could add your own orthotic insole, though the original footbed is removable in some pairs.

Are Rothy’s Waterproof?

Not exactly—but they’re water-resistant.

The signature knit material isn’t waterproof, so your feet will get wet in a downpour. However, the fabric dries quickly and doesn’t stain easily, which I appreciated during some surprise spring showers. If you’re looking for more water protection, check out their boots or the Weekend styles, which have added coatings.

Are Rothy’s Worth It?

Yes—for the right shopper.

They’re not the cheapest shoes you’ll find, but when you factor in durability, sustainability, and the washability, they’ve become a staple in my wardrobe. I’ve worn my first pair for over six months and they still look and feel amazing.

Considering how many cheaper flats I’ve trashed after a few months, the cost per wear makes Rothy’s a solid investment.

Does Rothy’s Have Sales?

They do! While Rothy’s doesn’t run flashy sales year-round, they have a “Final Few” section with steep markdowns and occasional promotions during seasonal events. First-time buyers often get a $20 off code, and teachers, students, and healthcare workers can apply for a 20% discount.

Also, keep an eye on Nordstrom sales—sometimes Rothy’s shoes show up at discounted prices there.

Rothy’s Shoes Return Policy

Their return policy is refreshingly easy. You’ve got 30 days to return or exchange your shoes, as long as they’re unworn and in original condition. Returns in-store are free, and mail returns cost a flat $4.99 fee.

In my case, I exchanged a pair of sneakers for a larger size—it was seamless, and the new pair arrived within a week.

My Favorite Rothy’s Styles in 2025

If you’re wondering where to start, here are my top picks:

• The Point – Sleek and chic. Great for office wear but runs snug.
• The Loafer – Versatile and polished with a touch more support.
• The Sneaker – Sporty but elevated. My weekend go-to.
• The Driver – The hidden gem! Cushioned, casual, and stylish.

Final Thoughts

Would I recommend Rothy’s? Absolutely. Whether you’re eco-conscious or just tired of throwing out worn-down flats, these shoes hit the sweet spot. They’re not perfect for every foot type, but with smart sizing choices and careful picks, they’re absolutely worth trying.

✅ Where to Buy: Shop Rothy’s Official Website