ThredUp Reviews – Must Read Before You Buy

Why I Gave ThredUp a Shot

I’ll admit it: I used to be skeptical about buying secondhand clothing online. But with rising prices and a growing concern for the environment, I decided to give ThredUp a try. I’d heard mixed things—some raving about the bargains, others warning about sketchy return experiences. So, I did what I always do—put it to the test myself.

Is ThredUp Legit? My Honest Take

If you’re wondering, “is ThredUp legit?” the short answer is yes. ThredUp is one of the largest online resale platforms in the U.S. and has been around since 2009. When I ordered from them, everything—from the product listings to checkout to delivery—worked as expected. My package arrived in branded, eco-friendly packaging and included everything I’d ordered.

The website is easy to navigate, and they list each item’s condition clearly (like “New with Tags” or “Gently Used”). That said, don’t expect any luxury shopping experience. It’s functional and reliable—but don’t hold your breath for boutique-style packaging.

Is ThredUp Worth It? Value & Savings Breakdown

This really depends on what you’re looking for. For buyers like me? Absolutely.

ThredUp allowed me to snag premium brand items (think Madewell, Banana Republic, and Free People) for up to 70% off their retail prices. That’s a huge win for my wallet. You can sort by size, brand, and condition, which makes hunting for treasures easier than rifling through a consignment store.

But what about selling? That’s where things get a bit murky. I tried selling a bag of clothes through their Clean Out Kit, and the payouts were… underwhelming. You might get $1–$5 per item, depending on the brand and condition. For decluttering? It’s fine. For making real money? Not so much.

So if you’re only looking to buy, ThredUp is worth it. If you’re planning to sell, temper your expectations.

Is ThredUp Used Clothing? What You Actually Get

Yes, ThredUp is entirely based on reselling used (pre-loved) clothing. But I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of what I received. Items marked “Like New” looked and felt brand new—some even still had the original tags attached.

One top I bought was labeled “Good” and had a tiny snag on the hem, but nothing too noticeable. Just be sure to read the descriptions and zoom in on photos—what you see is generally what you get.

How Long Does ThredUp Take to Ship?

In my experience, ThredUp shipping was fairly quick. I received my order within 5 business days, which was faster than I expected. Standard shipping is $5.99 unless your order qualifies for promotions or free shipping over a certain amount.

When it comes to returns (more on that soon), expect another 7–10 days for them to process and refund after they receive your returned item. So, patience is key.

ThredUp Return Policy: What You Should Know

ThredUp offers a 14-day return window, but there are a few catches.

If you choose to receive your refund as store credit, the return shipping label is free. If you want a refund to your original form of payment, they deduct a shipping label fee (usually around $10.99) from your refund.

I opted for the store credit (because I knew I’d be shopping again), and the return process was smooth. The label was emailed instantly, and I dropped the package off the same day.

⚠️ Tip: Not all items are returnable—especially “Final Sale” ones—so always check before you buy.

Pros & Cons of Using ThredUp

Here’s a quick breakdown from my experience:

Pros:

• Massive variety of brands and styles
• Budget-friendly and eco-conscious
• Reliable shipping and quality listings
• Easy returns (if you choose store credit)

Cons:

• Return fees if refunding to original payment
• Hit-or-miss condition for some lower-rated items
• Selling isn’t worth the effort if you want good payouts

Tips to Shop Smart on ThredUp

If you’re new to ThredUp, here are some things I learned the hard way:

• Use filters religiously—especially size and condition.
• Add favorite brands to your profile to get tailored recommendations.
• Always check item condition and zoom in on photos.
• If you love something, buy it—items sell out fast.

For sellers:

• Only send in clothes from popular brands in excellent condition.
• Be ready to wait weeks for processing.
• Don’t expect a payout that’ll fund your next vacation.

ThredUp Reviews Summary: My Final Verdict

So—should you use ThredUp?

If you’re a shopper looking for stylish deals and don’t mind secondhand clothes, absolutely. ThredUp is legit, the selection is impressive, and the value is real. It’s one of the best platforms I’ve found for sustainable fashion at unbeatable prices.

But if you’re expecting a luxury unboxing experience or trying to make money off your closet? You might want to look elsewhere.

At the end of the day, ThredUp helped me save money and reduce my environmental footprint. That’s a win-win in my book.

Quick FAQs

Is ThredUp legit?
Yes, it’s a reliable secondhand fashion platform that’s been around for over a decade.

Is ThredUp worth it?
For buying—definitely. For selling—only if you want to declutter.

Is ThredUp used clothing?
Yes, most items are pre-owned, though some are “New with Tags.”

How long does ThredUp take to ship?
Expect about 3–7 business days for delivery in the U.S.

ThredUp return policy?
14-day window. Free return label if you choose store credit; $10.99 fee for original payment refunds.

If you decide to shop, I recommend browsing directly from their site here:  https://www.thredup.com